AuthorPlanet

A sweet spot between traditional and self-publishing

  • Home
  • Book Proposals/Buy
  • About
    • Jody Rein
    • Author Planet
    • Praise
  • Work
    • Praise
    • Services List
    • Case Studies
    • Client Forms
  • Contact
    • Contact
    • Get Quote

Don’t Write for Free. Do Write for Free.

April 27, 2014 By Jody Rein 3 Comments

Man, it’s a confusing time to be a writer.

Book marketing experts say: “Give away content for free! Blog, tweet, pin, comment, contribute, give away your whole ebook, draft white papers. Do this to get attention, create relationships, join communities, build platforms, gain credibility…”

Gatekeepers say free content is destroying the world. Free content is unedited and unscreened. Writers can’t earn a living if they’re competing against others offering similar work for free. Untrustworthy and/or poor writing pervading the internet contributes to a culture with lower standards, little understanding and far less of the critical thinking  necessary to a civilized society.

I feel very strongly about this issue. I believe: both views are right.

Bottom Line Up Top: Be Good

There’s not a whole lot any individual writer can do to stem the avalanche of online content. And none of us can avoid giving content away for free, not if we want to keep our names out there–even Margaret Atwood tweets.  But we can strive to keep the bar high, whether we’re paid or not.

And that means taking the time to research. To re-read, and to edit. To write responsibly, not hastily.

Buy Good Writing, and Price Your Writing Well

Support those publications that pay their authors well–buy traditionally published books and subscribe to magazines and newspapers. And, as soon and as often as you can, charge appropriately for your work.

But of course, it’s not that simple. It’s not simple at all.

The Complexities

Scott Meslow’s article inThe Week, “Entertainment Weekly wants you to write for free. Don’t do it” prompted my writing this blog. In response to the news that Entertainment Weekly has created a platform to publish aspiring journalists’ articles for free, Mr. Meslow wrote “The precedent being set here is deeply troubling, and anyone who cares about the future of journalism should be disturbed by it.”

Mr. Meslow is the entertainment editor for TheWeek.com; I endorse many of the sentiments he expressed wholeheartedly and encourage you to read his essay.

And yet…The Week itself reprints, without payment (other than to newsfeeds), synopses of top stories reported elsewhere. I don’t condemn this. The Week also includes original reporting and essays, and supports a small paid staff. I’m glad to see a relatively new magazine finding a formula that works.

That formula, though, rests on not paying for the original reporting of the soundbites TheWeek reprints.

(Small newspapers, years ago, relied on newswires like AP for stories; that’s nothing new. I’m just pointing out the ironies.)

I’m on Scott’s Side, but the Slope is So Darn Slippery

One could say that the free material on The Week–the quick news takes compiled from other sources–is what grabs readers, who might then pay for the subscription that enables The Week  to pay its editors and contributors.

Much as today’s writers need to establish themselves somehow, to grab attention in some way–which usually means producing content for free.

I didn’t pay to read Scott’s article. I learned of it through someone’s tweet–I didn’t pay the tweeter, either. I didn’t pay to read the Salon article I jumped to after that, or the original Digiday report; I did pay to read the New York Times article about The Week. 

I faced a WordPress issue while writing. I jumped to a WordPress blog.

Paid content, unpaid content; paid writers, unpaid writers. I want to read quality material without paying for it. I’m part of the problem.

The Yin and the Yang

Scott’s  article didn’t mention Huffington Post, which  made millions on the backs of free blogs when it sold to AOL. I found the whole  Huffpo thing outrageous.  At the same time I know a few people whose businesses have grown markedly through their Huffpo fame.

Is it Better to Write for Free for EW than to Blog in Obscurity?

Before places like Huffpo and the new EW Community young writers would be trying to make their names through blogging and unpaid internships (which exploded in popularity around the same time as free content expectations…wonder what that’s about?).

(Pre-internet, young writers could find (low-paying) jobs at newspapers and magazines. Then again, years before that, artists of all kinds needed patrons to live, so I guess this is an ever-evolving tale.)

Back to You

I love giving advice to writers.  But this topic requires a conversation, not a soapbox. While I worry daily about the impact of devalued writing on society as a whole, individual writers have to break through the noise somehow.

So what do you think?

Spread the Word: on Twitter on Facebook on Google+

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Practical Publishing, Rants and Raves, Writing

Comments

  1. JodyRein says

    April 30, 2014 at 8:03 pm

    This is a test comment! Sorry, comments were disabled.

    Reply
  2. Lonnie Hanzon says

    April 30, 2014 at 8:27 pm

    It seems the financial models in all sectors of creative works is shifting. The writer, photographer, designer, painter are all being given the largest opportunities to communicate in history, for the least amount of commerce in history. I remember watching the television series Star Trek and thinking “oh, cmon, they don’t use money anymore?” how could that be?

    Reply
  3. Michael Larsen says

    May 3, 2014 at 1:29 am

    If, as Don Maass says, it takes five books to build an audience for
    your work, how many articles does it take? It’s about building a platform and a
    community of fans who will buy whoaever you sell, an investment that has a
    lifetime value. It takes as long as it takes, so writers have to have clear
    publishing goals and take the long view in developnig their craft and
    career.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

General Advice

Praise

Jody is beyond AWESOME! (more)
Mark Kistler
Kudos to Jody! She provided the substance and valuable information we sought. Jody has such an open, upfront approach; it was perfect for our casual atmosphere. (more)
Bonnie F. McCune
Jody actually takes the time to digest and understand what it is the writer is attempting to do before offering well thought out input. She has a more creative “big picture” mindset than most. (more)
Joe Lieberman
Jody has a gift for communicating in a clear, authoritative, engaging way that inspires trust and affection. (more)
Michael Larsen
Thanks to (Author Planet), I have been able to serve as the force behind several events that have resulted in change for good…(more)
Trisha Pritikin
Jody is the consummate professional; she’s creative, a pleasure to deal with and her knowledge of book publishing is profound. I couldn’t recommend her highly enough. (more)
Madeleine Morel
Working editorially with Jody Rein and her team at Author Planet is like getting a graduate degree in writing… (more)
Timothy Ashby
Jody gives thoughtful and thorough assessments, a value to me, and I appreciate it. I take her words to heart.  (more)
Bill Nesbit
Jody strives for the best, sets the bar high, and encourages others to do the same. Her success in the world of book publishing reflects her high standards. She knows the business inside and out–and her clients benefit! (more)
Dr. Lucy Spelman
Jody’s suggestions are clear and concise, and effectively point me in the direction I need to go with my project. I’ve had a most instructive and enjoyable time working with her! (more)
Louise Hauck

Recent Posts

  • Literary Agents: The Right Way to Nag
  • Thru Dec. 9! Holiday Raffle for Art Books, Lessons and Equipment

More Posts

Publishing News

Writing a book? Confused about publishing options? Need a marketing plan? Don’t miss the 7th annual Nonfiction Writers Conference—a virtual event unlike any other.

Join 15 top speakers May 3-5, 2017 from the comfort of your home or office. For details and registration got to NonfictionWritersConference.com.

Note: This is an affiliate link. Jody knows and respects the people who run this conference.

RSS General News

  • Penguin Random House Audio Acquires Playaway Products February 2, 2023
    Penguin Random House Audio has acquired Playaway Products, a producer of physical audio players and tablets preloaded with content. Launched in 2005 and based in Solon, Ohio, the company offers 36,000 titles and works with some 40,000 libraries and institutions.

RSS Publishing Trends Feed

  • International Bestsellers, January 2023 February 2, 2023 Nina Sabak

Self-Publishing News

RSS Self-pub news from PW

  • “The Plan Was Never to Publish” January 27, 2023
    How compiling a family history created an indie novelist.
  • Cover Redesign: 'Book of Days' by Douglas Bullis January 27, 2023
    Michelle Argyle at Melissa Williams Design reimagines the cover of 'Book of Days' by Douglas Bullis.
  • New Titles from Self-Publishers: January 2023 January 27, 2023
    Booksellers, publishers, librarians, and agents are encouraged to look at the 49 self-published titles below.

RSS The Book Designer Feed

  • What is a Preface? (Answers to Your 6 Most Common Questions) January 30, 2023
    Sometimes, it’s important to refresh your knowledge of the basic parts of a book. It might not be glamorous or exciting, but it’s an essential part of making sure your book contains everything a reader expects. One example of these plain but essential basic elements is the preface of a book. What exactly is it, […]
    Luke Worlock
  • Front Matter: Organizing the Beginning of Your Book January 30, 2023
    Self-Publishing Basics: How to Organize Your Book's Front Matter includes a checklist of front matter items.
    The Book Designer

Author Planet, Jody Rein News

Looking forward to the upcoming 2018 San Francisco Writers conference February 14-17, 2018. Jody will be teaching many classes, and offering free coaching sessions.

Hey, hey, teaching again at the wonderful 2018 Willamette Writers Conference, August 2-5 in Portland, Oregon. This time taught a SIX HOUR Query Master workshop–super fun!

Jody is doing the morning keynnote for theCastle Rock Writers Conference 2018, in October, in Castle Rock, Colorado.

Jody was interviewed by Stephanie Chandler in a teleseminar for the Nonfiction Authors Association on April 13, 2016.

Recent Tweets

  • Tweet Avatar RT @TruthBrigadeIl: Thank you @Demcast. You spoke truth to power in 2023 and will be our inspiration in 2023! Happy holidays.… https://t.co/nGTJYxMAhe 2 months
  • Tweet Avatar RT @smithbarbv: Thank you @DrKermitJones. You courageously stood up for truth and hope in 2022. Let’s keep up our truth-telling wor… https://t.co/mN6zd7tZ2e 2 months
  • Tweet Avatar RT @smithbarbv: Thank you @PVillescaz. You spoke truth to power in 2022 and will be my inspiration in 2023! Happy Holidays.… https://t.co/3WJZLzHAFR 2 months
Follow @authorplanet

Copyright © 2023 · Log in