AuthorPlanet

A sweet spot between traditional and self-publishing

  • Home
  • Book Proposals/Buy
  • About
    • Jody Rein
    • Author Planet
    • Praise
  • Work
    • Praise
    • Services List
    • Case Studies
    • Client Forms
  • Contact
    • Contact
    • Get Quote

Bookstores vs. Amazon Blog War

December 15, 2011 By Jody Rein 1 Comment

Istanbul BookshopBookstores vs. Amazon Blog War

There’s a blog war going on about the future of the independent bookstore, and it touches issues very important to me, so I’ll weigh in.

In a Slate blog I felt seemed inadequately researched, Farhad Manjoo raged against the “high prices” of books in bookstores, termed the marvelous essay by Richard Russo in the New York Times “hectoring,” and called books published by major houses all “mass-manufactured.”  Mr. Manjoo displayed no evidence that he had investigated what actually determines the pricing of books in bookstores, and I disagree strongly with his contention that traditional publishers–or anyone–is capable of “mass-manufacturing” quality books.

The kindler, gentler bookstore owners responded:

Word Brooklyn:

“If Amazon started reversing any of their more unsavory decisions, they might lose money in the short-term, but I think they’d end up making more money in the long-term, by cementing the loyalty of an entirely new set of consumers who always sort of want to buy things from Amazon, and sometimes give in and do, but feel guilty about it…’

And Lacy Simon of Hello Hello bookstore wrote in her blog quoted by Mr. Russo:

“If you let me, I’ll get to know you through your reading life and strive to find books that resonate with you. Amazon asks you to take advantage of my knowledge & my education (which I’m still paying for) and treat the space I rent, the heat & light I pay for, the insurance policies I need to be here, the sales tax I gather for the state, the gathering place I offer, the books and book culture I believe in so much that I’ve wagered everything on it” as if it were “a showroom for goods you can just get more cheaply through them.”

And Nathan Bransford posed the question to others today in his as-usual evenhanded and civil blog.

Here’s my take, from my comment on Nathan’s blog.  What do you think?

“… there’s a larger point to be made than selling “boatloads” of books.

The issue is fundamentally about a system of commerce that either supports or works against the promotion of quality literature. At the moment Amazon and its price wars are tipping the scales toward production of poor quality work.

No major house can consistently “mass-manufacture” or “produce” intellectual property–with the exception of predictable bestsellers, which take years to build. To exist, publishers have to find, hone, build and endorse new talent, and promote that talent through reliable outlets, ideally staffed and handsold by knowledgeable salespeople.

Sure, you can mass-produce some genre books following rules & conventions, but that’s where Amazon excels.

And sure, that model is disappearing. But I’m not willing to let it go without a fight. Let’s reframe the conversation–what can we do to keep quality literature alive if Amazon drives out of business all the places that publish and sell it?”

Spread the Word: on Twitter on Facebook on Google+

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Practical Publishing, Rants and Raves, Self Publishing Tagged With: Amazon, books, bookselling, bookstore

Comments

  1. Raymond M. Rose says

    January 30, 2012 at 6:17 pm

    It’s really interesting how so much of this conversation feels like a few decades ago when the Borders and the Barnes and Nobles were moving into the neighborhoods of indie bookstores. They were being perceived (which, they were) as pushing cheap books on people and undermining the hard work of the booksellers around the corner. Now Amazon, perhaps the biggest of the Big Box Store because it’s box can know no bounds.

    But here’s the thing: the indies still exist. Yes, in much lower numbers. But they are still alive.

    Amazon: look at Borders. Don’t make so many enemies that when you are sinking, no one will offer you a hand to pull your head back above water.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

General Advice

Praise

Jody’s suggestions are clear and concise, and effectively point me in the direction I need to go with my project. I’ve had a most instructive and enjoyable time working with her! (more)
Louise Hauck
Working editorially with Jody Rein and her team at Author Planet is like getting a graduate degree in writing… (more)
Timothy Ashby
Jody has a gift for communicating in a clear, authoritative, engaging way that inspires trust and affection. (more)
Michael Larsen
Jody strives for the best, sets the bar high, and encourages others to do the same. Her success in the world of book publishing reflects her high standards. She knows the business inside and out–and her clients benefit! (more)
Dr. Lucy Spelman
Kudos to Jody! She provided the substance and valuable information we sought. Jody has such an open, upfront approach; it was perfect for our casual atmosphere. (more)
Bonnie F. McCune
Jody is the consummate professional; she’s creative, a pleasure to deal with and her knowledge of book publishing is profound. I couldn’t recommend her highly enough. (more)
Madeleine Morel
Jody is beyond AWESOME! (more)
Mark Kistler
Jody actually takes the time to digest and understand what it is the writer is attempting to do before offering well thought out input. She has a more creative “big picture” mindset than most. (more)
Joe Lieberman
Jody gives thoughtful and thorough assessments, a value to me, and I appreciate it. I take her words to heart.  (more)
Bill Nesbit
Thanks to (Author Planet), I have been able to serve as the force behind several events that have resulted in change for good…(more)
Trisha Pritikin

Recent Posts

  • Literary Agents: The Right Way to Nag
  • Thru Dec. 9! Holiday Raffle for Art Books, Lessons and Equipment

More Posts

Publishing News

Writing a book? Confused about publishing options? Need a marketing plan? Don’t miss the 7th annual Nonfiction Writers Conference—a virtual event unlike any other.

Join 15 top speakers May 3-5, 2017 from the comfort of your home or office. For details and registration got to NonfictionWritersConference.com.

Note: This is an affiliate link. Jody knows and respects the people who run this conference.

RSS General News

  • 10 Things You (Probably) Didn't Know About James and Nora Joyce January 19, 2021
    James and Nora Joyce's first date, erotic letters, itinerant lifestyle, and more.

RSS Publishing Trends Feed

  • Top 5 Publishing Articles/Blog Posts of the Week 1/11-1/15 January 15, 2021 PT Editors

Self-Publishing News

RSS Self-pub news from PW

  • Autofiction: What It Is and What It Isn’t January 8, 2021
    Whether writing autobiographical fiction or memoir, writers must own their truths.
  • First Lines: January 2021 January 8, 2021
    Our monthly look at some of the best first lines by BookLife authors.
  • Pantser or Planner? January 8, 2021
    In many writing communities, there are two common approaches to writing a novel.

RSS The Book Designer Feed

  • e-Book Cover Design Awards, November 2020 December 28, 2020
    e-Book Cover Design Awards, November 2020 including The post e-Book Cover Design Awards, November 2020 appeared first on The Book Designer.
    Joel Friedlander
  • Self-Publishing: Carnival of the Indies Issue #123 December 25, 2020
    Self-Publishing: Carnival of the Indies Issue #123 including Darcy Pattison, Frances Caballo, Sandra Beckwith and many others The post Self-Publishing: Carnival of the Indies Issue #123 appeared first on The Book Designer.
    Joel Friedlander

Author Planet, Jody Rein News

Looking forward to the upcoming 2018 San Francisco Writers conference February 14-17, 2018. Jody will be teaching many classes, and offering free coaching sessions.

Hey, hey, teaching again at the wonderful 2018 Willamette Writers Conference, August 2-5 in Portland, Oregon. This time taught a SIX HOUR Query Master workshop–super fun!

Jody is doing the morning keynnote for theCastle Rock Writers Conference 2018, in October, in Castle Rock, Colorado.

Jody was interviewed by Stephanie Chandler in a teleseminar for the Nonfiction Authors Association on April 13, 2016.

Recent Tweets

  • Tweet Avatar RT @indivisiblefrr: Thank you for covering, @KDVR. Coloradans want accountability and we want freedom from elected officials who incite… https://t.co/zH3skHi6FM 1 week
  • Tweet Avatar @CharlesSchwab You didn't respond to @forbes request to stop donating to MoC's who spread lies that incite US terro… https://t.co/gmxWlw39OT 1 week
  • Tweet Avatar @TMobile Thanks for saying you're re-evaluating your donations to MoC's who spread lies that incite US terrorists t… https://t.co/btL121vMZt 1 week
Follow @authorplanet

Copyright © 2021 · Log in